Having a variety of different
products on the market in the same product category, it is essential for
advertisers to create the right message maybe through stating the benefits consumers
gains from the specific product and that this message is aimed at the right
targeted audience. The message is the key to the success of the advert. To
avoid competitive interference the advertising will be more effective if the
consumer is exposed to the advert close to when they are going to make the
purchase (Dahlén and Nordfält,
2004). However, it could be argued that
how can advertisers know when the consumer is going to make a purchase? Does
this mean releasing the advert for a shorter period of time?
Targeting smaller number of
consumers who have a strong preference for the product makes the advertising
more successful than targeting a larger number of consumers who may not be in
need of the product (Iyer et al, 2005). Not
only is this more effective but is cheaper and creates less waste. By directly
targeting consumers who are interested increases brand awareness as they
realise that your product offers exactly what they need and are looking for (Iyer
et al, 2005). Advertisers could always
lean on emotional advertising however this type of advertising is only
effective for certain product types, mainly low involvement or hedonic products
rather than high involvement or functional products (Kim and Morris, 2007).
Cars are one product category. BMW and Volkswagen are two brands offering
the same product of which appeal to two different types of consumer.
BMW is a product people associate with German innovation, business,
performance, males and is very much seen as a status symbol. They have built
their brand around customer experience and status. BMW is one of the core brands
alongside its competitors: Mercedes-Benz and Audi. BMW however is associated
with being the most masculine out of the three and according to an article by
the Guardian (2012) BMW is one of the premium brands that have seen a growth in European car sales since the economic downfall with a rise of 10.5% in the last
year and Audi with an increase of 1.4%. Mercedes however saw a downfall of
6.4%.
But what makes men act in a certain way? How do men choose which brand to follow from the many product alternatives? What influences their purchase decisions? Is it money, status or popularity? By understanding the consumer and their personality, the company really can aim and target their consumers more effectively by having a better understanding of their underlying purchasing patterns and buying behaviour (Mintel, 2011).
But what makes men act in a certain way? How do men choose which brand to follow from the many product alternatives? What influences their purchase decisions? Is it money, status or popularity? By understanding the consumer and their personality, the company really can aim and target their consumers more effectively by having a better understanding of their underlying purchasing patterns and buying behaviour (Mintel, 2011).
The following shows the two separate adverts for the BMW M5 M Performance edition car:
These adverts are based around the cars sleek, distinctive design and
performance. BMW were one of the main sponsors for the 2012 London Olympics and Paralympics so their advertising is being based around this idea, used as a
platform, striking to their consumers that their brand is all about
performance. From these adverts you can clearly see that BMW is really playing
on this idea.
This product in particular is being specifically targeted at males who
want to add some excitement to their driving experience, such as a toy which
they can play around and show off in. It is all about the cars performance and
BMW are trying to sell an ultimate driving experience which is why their slogan
is “The ultimate driving machine”.
The men who are of BMW’s targeted audience are seen as being passive,
accomplished, are exuberant and cultured (Mintel, 2011). As BMW is a premium brand, it is placed into
the category of being highly priced, with the M5 being worth around £95,000. A
Ferrari FF is priced at around £228,000 plus £45,000 VAT (Daily Mail, 2012) so
this BMW M5 is the next best thing regarding performance to the luxury car
brands on the market (such as Ferrari and Lamborghini etc ).
According to
Mintel (2011) BMW is targeted at A and B socio-economic groups.
Volkswagen is another German brand which is in the same product
category as BMW but aims it’s advertising at an entirely different target
audience.
The advert selected is for the 2012 Volkswagen Polo:
The advert is based around the evolving relationship between a protective
father and his daughter, from birth to moving away from home. The father bought
the car for his daughter through VW’s promise “stay in safe hands”. The advert
allows other fathers to emotionally connect with the people in the advert by
recalling their own memories. It’s not a big car but is of a decent size for
someone young and well made “Polo. Small
but tough”. VW Polo 2012 is set at a retail price of around £13,000 which is of
a much more affordable price range compared to the £95,000 BMW M5. By
estimation this would put the VW Polo consumer in either Socio-economic group B
or C1.
The demographics for VW Polo consumers are completely different to the BMW-M5.
The BMW-M5 is aimed at middle aged men who are in socio- economic groups A and
B so accomplished, cultured professionals with high incomes. VW Polo is aimed
at men however these men have different motives. The car itself is aimed
towards females who are going to be purchasing their first car. The advert however
is aimed at their dads who will help them look for or buy the best car for
them.
VW Polo plays on the safe, protective aspects that the car has to offer
which also offers parent’s peace of mind knowing their child will be protected
on the road. Considering that this is a high involvement product (As mentioned
previously) the advertising is very much emotional as they are playing on the
fear of losing a child and the love that is shared with the child as the
parents see them grow up and become more independent. This is one aspect of the
advert that makes it so effective thus emotional
advertising can be used for high involvement products. According to Berner
(2006) cited by BÜLBÜL and Menon (2010: p.169) companies which use emotional advertising
induce stronger long term loyalty which will affect consumer's behaviour as not
only would the father continue to buy from VW but the daughter would also
become loyal.
To summarise, the advert for VW displays more about
the emotional side of the product where as BMW is more about the functionality
and performance. Both similar products in the same product category but
advertised to two completely different audiences.
References
Audi (2012) Audi Official website. [Online]. Available from: http://www.audi.co.uk/ [Accessed: 6/11/12].
References
Audi (2012) Audi Official website. [Online]. Available from: http://www.audi.co.uk/ [Accessed: 6/11/12].
Becky Barrow (Friday 31st
August 2012) Lamborghini and Ferrari, the
recession-busters: Sales of upmarket cars soar despite the downturn. Daily Mail. [Online] Available from:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2196096/Lamborghini-Ferrari-cars-sold-longest-economic-downturn-HR-Owen.html
[Accessed: 5/11/12].
BMW (2012) BMW M5 M Performance Edition car website and information. [Online].
Available from: http://www.bmw.co.uk/bmwuk/pricesandspecifications/0,,1156_181242215__bs-TQ%3D%3D%40bb-RjEwTQ%3D%3D,00.html
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
BMW UK (2011) BMW M5 on the beach for the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games Advert. [Online]. Available from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1L-RzE3ymas&feature=relmfu [Accessed: 6/11/12].
BMW UK (2012) The new BMW M5 M Performance Edition Advert. [Online]. Available from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rg-t83l0KWE [Accessed: 6/11/12].
BMW UK (2011) BMW M5 on the beach for the London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic Games Advert. [Online]. Available from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1L-RzE3ymas&feature=relmfu [Accessed: 6/11/12].
BMW UK (2012) The new BMW M5 M Performance Edition Advert. [Online]. Available from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rg-t83l0KWE [Accessed: 6/11/12].
Bülbül, C.
and Menon, G. (2010) The power of emotional appeals in Advertising. Journal of Advertising research [Online]
50 (2) 169-180. Available from: Business Source Premier [Accessed: 5/11/12].
Cartype (2009) Audi logo. [Online]. Available from: http://www.cartype.com/pages/189/audi
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
Dan Milmo (Tuesday 16th
October 2012) European car sales fall for 12th month. The Guardian. [Online]. Available from: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2012/oct/16/european-car-sales-fall-new-car-registrations?INTCMP=SRCH
[Accessed: 5/11/12].
Equality Human Rights
Commission (2009) Socio-Economic groups explained. [Online]. Available
from: http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/uploaded_files/engaging_all_young_people_in_meaningful_learning_after_16_a_survey.pdf [Accessed: 5/11/12].
Grcea (2011) BMW logo. [Online]. Available from: http://www.grcea.com/sales-target-closer-for-bmw-than-previously-expected.html/bmw-logo
[Accessed:6/11/12].
Iyer, G.,
Soberman, D. and Villas-Boas,J,M. (2005) The Target of Advertising. Marketing
Science. [Online] 24 (3) 461-476. Available from: Academic Search Complete
[Accessed: 5/11/12].
Jooyoung, K. and J, D. Morris. (2007) The Power Of
Affective Response And Cognitive Structure In Product-Trial Attitude Formation.
Journal of Advertising.36 (1) 95-106. Available from: Business Source Premier
[Accessed: 5/11/12].
London Olympics (2012) Sponsors of the London 2012 Olympic and
Paralympic games UK. [Online]. Available from: http://www.london2012.com/about-us/the-people-delivering-the-games/olympic-partners/
[Accessed:6/11/12].
Mercedes-Benz (2012) Mercedes-Benz Official website. [Online].
Available from: http://www2.mercedes-benz.co.uk/content/unitedkingdom/mpc/mpc_unitedkingdom_website/en/home_mpc/passengercars.html
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
Micael
Dahlén, N. and Nordfält, J. (2004) Interference Effects of a Purchase on
Subsequent Advertising Within the Category. Journal of
Current Issues and Research in Advertising. [Online] 26 (1) 1-8. Available from: Business Source Premier [Accessed:
5/11/12].
Mintel (2011) Marketing to men- UK- January 2011. [Online].
Available from: Mintel [Accessed: 5/11/12].
Republic of code (2010) VW Logo. [Online]. Available from: http://www.republicofcode.com/tutorials/photoshop/volkswagen/
[Accessed:6/11/12].
The supercars (2011) Image of Lamborghini. [Online].
Available from: http://www.thesupercars.org/lamborghini-super-cars/2009-lamborghini-gallardo-lp-550-2-valentino-balboni/
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
The Telegraph (2012) Image of Ferrari. [Online]. Available
from: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/car-manufacturers/ferrari/5931105/Ferrari-458-photo-gallery.html
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
The views paper (2008) Image
of brands. [Online]. Available from: http://theviewspaper.net/brands-and-us/
[Accessed: 13/10/12].
Volkswagen (2012) VW Polo Official website and information. [Online].
Available from: http://www.volkswagen.co.uk/new/polo-v/home
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
Volkswagen UK (2012) VW Polo Dad Advert. [Online]. Available
from: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeKuFs0KxO8
[Accessed: 6/11/12].
Wikia (2011) Mercedes-Benz logo. [Online]. Available from: http://classiccars.wikia.com/wiki/File:Mercedes_logo.jpg
[Accessed:6/11/12].